Skip links

Trump Seeks to Further Limit Federal Judges’ Power to Block Government Policies

November 15, 2026

US President Donald Trump’s administration is seeking to further restrict the power of federal judges to block government policies, in a move that could strengthen the executive branch’s ability to implement its agenda despite legal challenges.

An appeal filed by the Justice Department and now pending before the US Supreme Court calls on the justices to limit judges’ longstanding authority to invalidate regulations issued by federal agencies. The administration argues that courts should restrict any relief to the specific individuals or organisations bringing a case, rather than blocking a regulation nationwide.

The appeal follows a 2025 Supreme Court ruling that restricted the use of nationwide, or “universal”, injunctions. That decision limited judges’ ability to prevent the government from enforcing policies against people who were not directly involved in the lawsuits.

However, the ruling did not address a separate power under the Administrative Procedure Act (APA), a 1946 law governing the operation of federal agencies. Courts have traditionally used the law to invalidate regulations they find unlawful, with decisions often applying nationwide.

Aditya Bamzai, an administrative law expert at the University of Virginia, said a victory for the Trump administration could allow the government to continue enforcing regulations against everyone except the plaintiffs in a case, potentially for years while legal proceedings continue.

Such a decision would give the executive branch greater flexibility, although its impact could depend on the policies pursued by a particular administration, Bamzai said.

Challenge to Judicial Authority

The case stems from a legal challenge brought by Texas medical providers against federal regulations introduced to limit unexpected medical bills. The rules were designed to protect patients from unexpected charges by hospitals and healthcare providers outside their insurance networks.

A Texas association representing medical doctors, air-ambulance providers and other parties argued that the regulations violated the APA and artificially reduced insurance reimbursement rates.

In August, the New Orleans-based 5th US Circuit Court of Appeals invalidated parts of the regulations nationwide, citing violations of the law.

The Trump administration is not challenging the appeals court’s findings on the legality of the regulations. Instead, it is asking the Supreme Court to determine whether judges have the authority to invalidate federal agency policies on a nationwide basis under the APA.

The administration argues that the law does not give courts such broad powers and that any decision should apply only to the parties involved in a particular case.

The Supreme Court is expected to consider whether to hear the appeal early next year.

Concerns Over Executive Overreach

The administration’s latest move forms part of a broader effort to reduce the ability of courts to obstruct presidential policies.

Since returning to office in January 2025, Trump has faced hundreds of legal challenges over measures involving immigration, mass deportations, diversity programmes and transgender rights, among other issues. His administration and political allies have repeatedly criticised judges who have blocked or delayed its policies.

Supporters of the courts’ existing authority argue that it is an important safeguard against executive overreach and helps ensure that federal regulations are applied consistently.

Ronald Levin, a law professor at Washington University in St. Louis, said some unlawful regulations should be removed entirely rather than being blocked only for the individuals who challenged them.

He pointed to food-safety and vehicle-manufacturing standards as examples of rules that cannot reasonably operate differently for different groups.

Levin said judges should retain the power to invalidate regulations nationwide when circumstances make such action necessary.

If the Supreme Court sides with the Trump administration, Levin warned, it could take longer for challengers to have unlawful regulations removed.

Previous Supreme Court Ruling

The Supreme Court’s 2025 decision restricting nationwide injunctions came during litigation over Trump’s attempt to end birthright citizenship, a right long recognised in the United States.

That ruling dealt with the authority of federal judges to issue nationwide injunctions rather than the constitutionality of Trump’s birthright citizenship policy itself.

In a separate 6-3 decision in June 2025, the Supreme Court rejected the administration’s birthright citizenship policy as unconstitutional.

Although former President Joe Biden’s administration had also asked the Supreme Court to restrict nationwide injunctions in 2023, the court did not take up that request at the time and ruled in Biden’s favour on other grounds in the relevant case.

The Trump administration’s latest effort could also face opposition from several states, including Republican-led Texas and Florida.

Those states previously urged the 5th Circuit Court of Appeals not to weaken the APA, describing it as an important safeguard against federal government overreach and violations of state sovereignty.

“The APA is a critical tool … to curb federal overreach and incursions into state sovereignty by executive-branch agencies,” the states said in their submission.

The Supreme Court’s decision on whether to take up the case could therefore have significant implications for the balance of power between the presidency, federal agencies and the judiciary.

This website uses cookies to improve your web experience.
Home
Account
Cart
Search